But Still It Falls: On the Rate of Profit

With regard to the rate of profit ( s/C , where s = surplus-value, and C = total capital laid out), and the factors that influence it, the fundamental relation that Marx establishes (in chapter 3 of volume 3 of Capital) is π = δ.v/C , in which π = rate of profit, δ = rate of surplus-value ( s/v ), and v = variable capital (capital laid out as wages): ‘The rate of profit is thus determined by two major factors; the rate of surplus-value and the value composition of the capital.’ The rate of profit increases in function of a rise in the rate of surplus-value, and falls in function of an increase in the constant part of capital with respect to variable. Marx’s purpose in this chapter was to delink the rate of surplus-value from the rate of profit: to show that the same rate of surplus-value can find expression as different rates of profit, and that the same rate of profit can arise from different rates of surplus-value.

It is intrinsic to capitalist production that the productivity of labour rises. This is because it is inherent on each capital to seek a surplus profit, and a surplus profit is achieved by increasing the productivity of labour over that of competing capitalists in order to reduce per-unit output prices (most importantly as set out in Capital volume 1, chapter 12; and volume 3, chapter 10). A capitalist that achieves this is able to realise a surplus profit because the per-unit cost price of her commodity product falls below that of her competitors’, allowing her, if she sells at the old price, or even below it (which she will almost certainly have to do to fulfil conditions of social demand) to achieve a rate of profit on her capital higher than that her competitors do. Yet when the new productive technique is generalised in the sector of production in question (and then beyond it), when a new level of productivity of labour is reached, when the socially-necessary value (labour-time) of the commodity in question falls to a new level – ignoring for the moment the question of social demand and the realisation of the commodity value – what happens then?

More (pdf: 184KB): But still it falls

7 thoughts on “But Still It Falls: On the Rate of Profit

  1. Pingback: Returning to Heinrich | Michael Roberts Blog

  2. Hey I have a question on page 3 whats up with this?
    100c+100 (s+v) / 100

    The 100c is the value of raw materials…
    Is the 100 (s+v) split up between capitalist and worker so 50 each?
    And whats the 100 on the bottom for

    • The 100c is raw materials (constant capital; there’s no fixed capital in this example); the 100(s+v) is new value produced in production (50v = wages + 50 surplus-value). The 100 on the bottom is the number of units produced: 100c+100(s+v) / 100 is the per-unit price.

  3. Page 3

    In the next production period, the
    third here, let us imagine that productivity doubles again: 400 units (but now at €0.75 per unit – 75 % of their
    former value) are transformed by the same labour. The per-unit commodity price is now

    Then you put the equation over 100… Shouldn’t you put it over 400?

  4. Pingback: The Handbook of Karl Marx: profitability, crises and financialisation | Michael Roberts Blog

  5. Pingback: The Handbook of Karl Marx: profitability, crises and financialisation – The New Dark Age

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s